A decision has been issued by the Supreme Court of Texas in regard to a personal injury case brought by a woman who was injured in two car accidents just a few months apart. According to the decision, the woman was driving in Zapata County, Texas when a truck rear-ended her vehicle. The woman claims that her aunt took her to the hospital. However, the record does not show any medical records from that visit to the emergency room. Shortly after the accident, the woman went to see a surgeon after she began experiencing neck and back pain. She began physical therapy for approximately two months.
Shortly after her physical therapy ended, the woman was involved in yet another car accident. This time, she was transported to the hospital in an immobilization board. She told the doctors that she was having pains in her head, neck, and chest. She then went back to the doctor at the end of the month, when it was discovered she had two herniated discs.
The woman then sued the employer of the truck driver from the first accident, claiming that his negligence caused her injures. Both she and the defendants called different doctors as expert witnesses. The defendants claimed that the woman was not suffering from a trauma-related injury and the second accident could have been the cause of her pain. The lower courts dismissed the plaintiff's pretrial motion to exclude all evidence of the second accident. However, the Supreme Court of Texas found that evidence from that accident was relevant and remanded the case for a new trial.